What's actually in each pie

Every pie at Perfect Pies by Pablo starts with real ingredients — no mixes, no shortcuts. Here's what goes into each one, along with the allergens you'll want to know about before you order. One important note up front: all our pies are baked in a shared kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, eggs, tree nuts (pecans and walnuts), and soy. Cross-contact is possible in every pie, even the ones that don't call for those ingredients directly. We're not a certified gluten-free or nut-free facility, and we won't pretend otherwise.

Sweet pies

• Apple — Pennsylvania-grown Granny Smith and Honeycrisp apples, brown sugar, cinnamon, lemon, butter, hand-laid lattice crust. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Pecan — Brown butter, dark corn syrup, a splash of bourbon, toasted whole and halved pecans. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs, tree nuts.
• Key Lime — Fresh-juiced key limes, sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, buttery graham crust, torched Italian meringue. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Chocolate Silk — Bittersweet 70% chocolate, butter, eggs, sugar, chocolate-cookie crust, hand-whipped cream, shaved chocolate. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs, soy.
• Banana Cream — Vanilla pastry cream, fresh sliced bananas, vanilla-wafer crust, whipped cream. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs. (Local pickup or delivery only — this one doesn't ship.)
• Strawberry Rhubarb (May–August) — Local PA strawberries, Snavely's Farm rhubarb, lattice crust, coarse sugar. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Pumpkin (October–December) — Sugar pumpkins (not canned), cinnamon, ginger, clove, fresh cream, eggs, single crust. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Sweet Potato (November–December) — Roasted sweet potatoes, brown sugar, a splash of bourbon, fresh nutmeg. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.

Savory pies

• Chicken Pot Pie — Roasted chicken thighs, carrots, celery, peas, thyme-scented cream sauce, double crust. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Shepherd's Pie — Ground beef, carrots, peas, onion, Worcestershire, mashed potato top. Contains: wheat, dairy. (No bottom crust, no eggs in the filling.)
• Steak & Mushroom — Beef chuck braised in red wine and stock, cremini mushrooms, pearl onions, all-butter shortcrust. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Spinach & Feta — Wilted spinach, feta, lemon zest, dill, phyllo top. Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs.
• Pizza Pie — House tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, deep-pan crust. Contains: wheat, dairy.

A word on substitutions

We get asked about gluten-free crusts, dairy-free fillings, and vegan versions pretty regularly — and we wish we could say yes. Right now, we can't do any of those reliably, and we'd rather be straight with you than guess. If you have a serious allergy or restriction, Clarisse — our head baker — is the right person to talk to. She knows every ingredient in every pie and will give you an honest answer, including recommending something else entirely if what you need isn't something we can safely make.

Reach her (and the rest of the team) at support@perfectpies.club — just mention your specific allergy or restriction in the subject line and she'll get back to you personally.

---

Got a question Clarisse hasn't answered yet? Drop us a line at support@perfectpies.club — we'd love to help you find the right pie.